The Flourishing Journal

Why did we stop making beautiful things?

  • Post published:
You are currently viewing Why did we stop making beautiful things?
Why did we stop making beautiful things?
Article

Why did we stop making beautiful things?

Dr. Victor Counted  ·  October 15, 2026  ·  20 min read

Branded · Printable
The Flourishing Journal / CountLife Institute

The Psychology of Beauty in Everyday Design

We know what beauty costs. We have become less certain how to value what it gives us.

By Victor Counted · Culture & Society

I swiped through nineteen slides on instagram, nodding at each one. A gilded mirror beside a black rectangle. A brass umbrella stand beside a perforated tube. A carved door handle beside a steel bar. The post wanted to know why we stopped making beautiful things, and I found myself agreeing with it. I have spent years studying how the places we inhabit shape our capacity to flourish. Yet these images made me pause over something I had rarely considered and just recently have been made aware of how beautiful things around us can be. Thanks to the work of sociologist Brandon Vaidyanathan and a reminder from Umut Korkut, who has reminded me of how much beauty we encounter through the ordinary objects around us.

The instagram post asked why we had stopped making beautiful things. Looking at those comparisons, I felt drawn to the question and the sense of loss behind it.

Each pair placed an extraordinary object from the past beside an ordinary product from the present. A palace mirror was compared with something manufactured for a thousand hotel bathrooms. Two centuries of surviving craftsmanship stood against a shipment from last month.

For a second, I thought that the comparison was unfair. Every generation has produced its share of ugly buildings and sometimes poorly made furniture or forgettable objects. Time has simply done us the favor of removing much of the evidence. We don’t hear more about the contemporaries of Leonardo da Vinci, who might have made really poor art that did not see the light of day. We visit the old houses that survived and rarely think about the thousands that did not in their time.

Some of the modern objects were beautiful, too. The plain church above in the collection had generous windows and proportions that invited the eye to rest. I could imagine sitting there for an hour without wanting anything added to the walls.

Yet I could not dismiss the feeling that the images had stirred.

As I swipe through the instagram photos, the question that lingered was much bigger than whether we have lost our taste for carved doors and ornamental ceilings.

Why have we become so willing to accept environments that meet our practical needs while asking so little of our capacity for beauty?

I suspect the answer lies in how we make things and the value we assign to them. Also, there is a question of who ultimately benefits from the care we put into our shared surroundings.

Beauty became expensive

Look closely at an old carved mirror. Someone spent hours shaping the leaves around its frame. Each curve required some sort of judgment. A machine can now produce a serviceable mirror in minutes, and that is an extraordinary achievement. It has made useful objects available to people who could never have afforded them before.

But the economics of craftsmanship have also changed.

Economists describe part of this problem through Baumol’s cost disease. When productivity rises rapidly in one industry and slowly in another, the labor-intensive activity becomes relatively more expensive. A factory can manufacture thousands of identical door handles in the time a craftsperson takes to finish a handful.

This helps explain why intricate workmanship increasingly appears in luxury markets. It does not establish that beauty itself must be expensive. A carefully proportioned window, a pleasing color, or a thoughtfully designed public bench may require little ornament. Good industrial design can also make beautiful objects affordable.

The most important economic question concerns which qualities survive when institutions face pressure to reduce costs.

Take for instance a developer constructing an apartment building. Every additional detail has a price, and the developer can calculate the cost of better materials, larger windows, and more thoughtful landscaping. But the eventual benefits may accrue to tenants, neighbors, and future generations. Those people are rarely present when the construction budget is approved.

The financial calculation is understandable but can also be incomplete.

We began to confuse simplicity with seriousness

The history of modern design helps explain another part of the story.

In the early twentieth century, Austrian architect Adolf Loos challenged the cultural obsession with ornament. In his influential lecture Ornament and Crime, delivered around 1910 and published in French in 1913, he associated the removal of unnecessary decoration with cultural progress.

Loos was responding to genuine problems. Building an ornament could consume enormous amounts of time and labor. Besides, fashionable decorative styles could become obsolete quickly. Not to mention craftspeople often bore the costs of producing goods that wealthy consumers would soon replace. Try knitting a beanie with fine wool and you understand what I mean.

To be fair, Loos’ critique deserves to be taken seriously.

Modernism also gave us extraordinary architecture and everyday objects. The best designers today understand that ‘beauty’ could emerge from proportion and the functional use of a thing. There is elegance in a well-made steel chair and dignity in a minimalist room that allows people to move comfortably.

But somewhere along the way, a preference for simplicity evolved into a suspicion of decoration. I remember watching a show where a group of professionals are tasked to redecorate people’s houses. One of the interior designers came in to a nicely decorated — though ‘aged’ — house and made a comment about it looking like a place where a serial killer lives. And similar sentiments are made about homes with unique sets of ornaments.

In some settings, plainness came to signal efficiency and restraint. Elaborate craftsmanship became easier to dismiss as indulgence or ‘doing too much’.

This was never a universal cultural shift, though. I think that different societies continued to produce rich decorative traditions, and contemporary designers still do remarkable work. However, the influence of standardization and minimalist aesthetics is difficult to miss in the institutional spaces many of us occupy.

Walk into enough newly constructed offices, schools, airports, or apartment buildings, and the resemblance becomes striking. Similar flooring. Similar lighting. Similar furniture. Similar walls.

Some of these spaces function beautifully. Others seem designed to avoid giving anyone a reason to object.

But, really, why have we allowed the cost of creating a place to overshadow the experience of living in it?

We lost some of our language for defending beauty

In 1999, Harvard literary scholar Elaine Scarry published On Beauty and Being Just, a defense of the place of beauty in intellectual and moral life.

Scarry observed that scholars continued to study beautiful poems, paintings, and other works while becoming increasingly reluctant to discuss beauty itself. She examined arguments that beauty could distract from injustice or conceal unequal power.

These concerns do deserve some attention because, if you are a good history student, you know that many magnificent buildings have been constructed through exploitation. Some of history’s most admired objects were created for elites while the people who made them lived in abject poverty. So, beauty can serve exclusion and domination.

But Scarry also offered another possibility. The fact that our encounter with beauty can draw our attention beyond ourselves and position our concern for what exists outside our immediate interests.

I find that possibility important for the science of human flourishing.

Human beings respond to their surroundings through more than practical judgment. We notice whether a place invites us to stay, whether its features reward our attention, and whether we feel comfortable occupying it. These experiences can influence how we relate to a place and to the people who share it.

In many organizations, beauty is often the first thing we sacrifice to cost. I could imagine a public library purchasing new furniture. The library committee will likely discuss price, durability, maintenance, and accessibility. All are legitimate concerns, of course. But who will ask whether the furniture makes the library a place people actually enjoy spending time?

I have sat in enough board meetings to know how easily such questions get overlooked. We can calculate the cost of a chair and estimate how long it will last. But how do we account for the pleasure of a teenager reading beside a window or the sense of welcome an older resident experiences upon entering the place?

These benefits rarely appear on a purchasing spreadsheet. And when beauty has no place in our calculations, it becomes easier to leave it out of our decisions.

The unclaimed return of beauty

I have come to think of this as the unclaimed return of beauty..

When someone invests in making a shared environment beautiful, many of the benefits may flow to people who did not pay for it. A passerby enjoys the flowers outside a building. A child remembers the library where she first loved reading. A resident takes pleasure in walking along a carefully maintained street.

The benefits may accumulate over years. They may also be difficult to separate from other features of the environment.

Economists have long studied such problems through the concepts of externalities and public goods. My concern is with the human experience behind those concepts.

A beautiful environment can give something to people who never appear in the original financial calculation.

Research offers reasons to take this possibility seriously.

In a 2019 study published in Scientific Reports, Chanuki Seresinhe and colleagues examined 138,407 reports of momentary happiness from 15,444 smartphone users in England. They combined these reports with crowdsourced assessments of how scenic different locations appeared.

People reported greater happiness in more scenic environments, even after the researchers accounted for factors such as weather, activity, and local income. The association also appeared in built-up areas after controlling for green space.

These findings cannot establish that beautiful surroundings cause happiness. People may choose environments that suit their preferences, and scenic ratings cannot capture everything that makes a place meaningful. Momentary happiness is also only one aspect of flourishing.

Still, the findings challenge the assumption that aesthetics are merely decorative concerns with little relevance to human well-being.

What we build becomes part of the environment in which people conduct their lives, and therefore, deserves serious attention.

I also recognize the tension from experience. I have sat on the side of the table where budgets are designed and every additional expense requires justification. I have approved cheaper options because they met the specification and I will probably do so again.

There is no wisdom in pretending resources are unlimited. A beautiful public building that consumes money needed for essential services may be a poor public decision.

But this is precisely why we need a better account of value. We should be able to ask whether a modest additional investment will improve the daily experience of hundreds of people over many years. Sometimes it will. And other times, it will not.

Regardless, the question deserves a place in our decision-making. . .

Beauty can communicate regard

There is another dimension to this problem that I find especially compelling.

Let’s return to the two fountains in the original image collection.

One has a lion’s head carved into stone, with water flowing into a basin. The other is a simple steel cylinder with a functional spout.

Both provide water. Both could be beautiful. Both could be poorly designed.

But suppose the first fountain was built for an ordinary public square. Someone decided that people passing through that square deserved something worth looking at. The designer could have provided water alone. Instead, the fountain offered an additional experience of ‘beauty’.

I think of that gesture as regard.

Regard is the attention we give to the experience of another person when we make something they will use. It can appear in the shape of a handle, the placement of a window, or the care with which a public garden is maintained.

It does not require expensive materials. Nor does it require a particular architectural style.

A poorly placed marble bench may communicate less regard than a simple wooden seat that offers shade to an elderly person. A hospital corridor with good lighting and clear directions may serve its users better than an ornate entrance hall.

This is why beauty should remain connected to human flourishing. We must ask how the experience of a place relates to the people who inhabit it.

A beautiful object does not automatically communicate care. A lavishly decorated building can make some people feel excluded. People also differ in what they find beautiful. Culture, memory, familiarity, and personal experience shape aesthetic judgment, as we have shown in our recent study on beauty (see Lomas et al., 2026).

Regard, therefore, asks more of the maker than the pursuit of visual admiration. It questions whether we have considered the people who will encounter what we create.

In the different continents where I have lived, I have encountered remarkable examples of this care in ordinary objects. A woven basket. A clay pot. A painted doorway. A courtyard arranged so that neighbors can sit together in the evening.

None requires a palace.

So, if we allow luxury to define beauty, we make it easier to reserve beauty for those who can afford it. We also overlook the forms of craftsmanship that communities have developed through generations of practical knowledge.

The person who makes a beautiful basket may be expressing as much artistic judgment as the designer of an expensive chair.

Beauty, therefore, belongs in ordinary life.

The beautiful world also needs people willing to care for it

Sequel to my last article on stewarship, there is one more problem with our nostalgia for the past.

We admire old buildings partly because people have maintained them. Someone repaired the roof, cleaned the stone, restored the windows, and even decided that the building deserved another generation of life.

We rarely see the full history of that labor.

A society that wants beautiful things must care about what happens after they are made. I remember seeing remnants of beauitful Victorian architectures growing up; most of those houses were rarely cared for. My grandfather had one (wish I had some pictures to share). Materials age. Public spaces deteriorate. Fashion changes. A poorly maintained ornament can become an obstacle or a hazard.

Sometimes the most responsible choice is to repair what already exists. Sometimes it is to build something simple, durable, and easy to maintain.

This is the intersection beauty and stewardship. And so, the question extends beyond what we can afford to construct today. It must include, but not limited, to what we are prepared to maintain for those who come after us.

I find this especially relevant to how we think about flourishing. Human well-being unfolds over time and within relationships. The places we inherit do shape our possibilities, and the places we leave behind will shape the lives of people we may never meet.

Whether it is a public garden, a library, a school, or a neighborhood street — they can all become part of that inheritance. And our responsibility is to consider the people who will live with the consequences of our decisions.

What will we choose to make beautiful?

Recently, I had a chat with a colleague Brandon Vaidyanathan about a book project he is writing on beauty. I already loved the proposed title before anticipating what would be inside, but I know that most of my reflective thoughts in this section will be captured in the book. And it is about the commitment, regardless of who you are and your place in society, to make beautiful things.

So, I put my phone down after those instagram slides with much of the same feeling I had when I began. I still wanted to live in a world with more beautiful things.

But I no longer thought the answer was simply to return to carved mirrors, elaborate ceilings, or the architecture of another century.

The question has become more immediate; at least for me.

Somewhere this year, someone will decide what a new classroom should look like. Someone will choose the furniture for a public library. A landlord will select the materials for an apartment building. A city will decide whether to repair a fountain or replace it with something cheaper.

These decisions will involve budgets, deadlines, and legitimate practical constraints. The people making them will have good reasons to consider cost.

I hope someone will also ask what the space will feel like to the people who spend their lives there.

I hope they will ask whether a better design could make the place more welcoming and whether a small detail might give someone pleasure. And perhaps, whether the object they are about to purchase will still deserve care ten years from now.

I cannot promise that every beautiful thing will make us happier. Human flourishing is too complex for that claim.

But this I know—based on some emerging empirical evidence—that beauty makes a flourishing life. We lose something when we stop asking what our surroundings give to the people who inhabit them.

We know how to calculate what it costs to make a room. So, we should probably also learn to ask what kind of life that room makes possible.

And the next time you have a say in how something is made, what will you ask for?

I hope, truely, that you will advocate for beauty…

Further reading

Scarry, E. (1999). On Beauty and Being Just. Princeton University Press.

Seresinhe, C. I., Preis, T., MacKerron, G., & Moat, H. S. (2019). Happiness is greater in more scenic locations. Scientific Reports, 9, 4498.

Loos, A. Ornament and Crime. Lecture delivered around 1910; first published in French in 1913.

Lomas, T., Padgett, R. N., Pawelski, J. O., Makridis, C. A., de la Rosa Fernández Pacheco, P. A., Kim, Y.-I., Breedlove, T., Cowden, R. G., Counted, V., Johnson, B. R., & VanderWeele, T. J. (2026). The prevalence and predictors of experiences of beauty in 22 countries: An international assessment of aesthetic appreciation in the Global Flourishing Study. Applied Research in Quality of Life, 21(2), 469–504.

THE FLOURISHING JOURNAL
Published by the CountLife Institute
Exploring the science, culture, and practice of human flourishing.
Published in The Flourishing Journal
Flourishing for the common good.

THE CONVERSATION

What stayed with you?

Share a thought or question about this essay. Please keep comments relevant and respectful.

No approved comments yet. You are welcome to start the conversation.

Join the conversation

No account is needed. New comments appear after review. Your email address will not be displayed publicly.

A LETTER FROM THE JOURNAL

Keep a little room
for a good idea.

Ideas for a flourishing life.
Receive the next essay.

The Flourishing Journal
Flourishing for the common good.

COUNTLIFE · NEWSLETTER

Ideas for a flourishing life.

Sign up to receive The Flourishing Journal by email.

FOLLOW YOUR CURIOSITY

Read next

SOMETHING ON YOUR MIND?Continue the conversation Speaking, research, media, or a personal note

How can we help?

Choose the form that fits your enquiry.

Contact Dr. Counted

COUNTLIFE · CONTACT

Let’s connect.

Send a question or a message to Dr. Victor Counted.

Speaking engagements

COUNTLIFE · SPEAKING

Invite Dr. Counted to speak.

Tell us about your event and the conversation you hope to begin.

Media and interviews

COUNTLIFE · MEDIA

Start a media conversation.

Enquire about interviews, commentary, or podcast appearances.

Research partnerships

COUNTLIFE · RESEARCH

Explore a research partnership.

Share your research question and the collaboration you have in mind.

Books and courses

COUNTLIFE · BOOKS

Ask about books or courses.

Get in touch about learning resources, group use, or an existing purchase.