Revisiting Gorer’s Pornography of Death
Revisiting the Pornography of Death
Americans will spend $4.3 billion on Halloween decorations this year. An essay on death and denial written 71 years ago explains what we are buying, and why it should make us hesitate.By the last week of October, most of us have learned to walk past a dead body without breaking stride. A skeleton hangs beside a front door. A severed hand reaches out of a flower bed. A bloodied figure slumps against a porch rail where, on Saturday night, children will line up for candy. Someone chose these things, paid for them and placed them where we would see them. They expect us to enjoy the view.
I have walked past those lawns as easily as anyone.
This week, my son brought a Halloween-themed worksheet home from his Christian school.
A quick Google search described the roll-a-jack-o-lantern dice game activity as “a fun dice and drawing or crafting game where players roll a die to build a pumpkin face piece by piece.” I understood why someone might see it as harmless classroom play. But I had taught my son that our family does not celebrate Halloween, and I had hoped his school would support that choice.
He knows where we stand. I am still teaching him how to express that belief with kindness toward people who choose differently. Seeing the worksheet made me wonder what he would make of the different messages he was receiving from home and school. Had the school considered that some families might have good reasons to decline an activity it presented as fun?
Halloween falls on a Saturday this year, and the National Retail Federation expects Americans to spend $13.5 billion on the holiday. Decorations make up $4.3 billion of that, and nearly four in five holiday shoppers plan to buy them. Most of the money goes to pumpkins, scarecrows and paper bats. Some of it buys something darker. In 2019 the developmental psychologist Jacqueline Woolley described what had begun to appear in placid suburbs: lifelike human figures meeting violent ends, some impaled, some hanged.
I want to ask what we are being invited to enjoy. My answer leads me to a conclusion many readers will resist. Families who care about the dignity of human life have good reason to treat this holiday with far more caution than most of us do.
The best case for Halloween
The defense of Halloween deserves a fair hearing, and its strongest version taps on ‘innocent’ play. Children try on other selves. Adults get permission to be ridiculous. A monster shrinks once you can pull off its mask. Neighbors who barely wave in July open their doors to one another, and there is real warmth in that.
Research lends the defense some support. In a field study published in Psychological Science in 2020, researchers from Aarhus University fitted 110 visitors to a Danish haunted house with heart-rate monitors and asked them to rate each scare. Enjoyment peaked at a middle level of fear. It fell away when visitors were too frightened, and also when they were not frightened enough. The lead author compared the pattern to what scientists see in ordinary play. A separate study led by Coltan Scrivner, run during the Covid-19 pandemic, found that horror fans reported less psychological distress in 2020 than other people did.
Even Jacqueline Woolley, who studies how children separate fantasy from reality, calls Halloween a kind of playground. Ghosts and skeletons let children explore the border between life and death while feeling safe.
I will admit that this argument nearly persuaded me. As a psychologist, I teach that avoidance feeds fear and that controlled exposure can loosen its grip. If a plastic skeleton helps a seven-year-old feel less helpless before death, I ought to welcome it.
Then I looked at what the studies measured. The haunted-house study measured pleasure in the moment. Scrivner has written that his pandemic study was not designed to test cause and effect, and that horror fans did better on distress but showed no edge on positive resilience. None of this work shows that Halloween helps anyone face a real death, sit beside a dying parent or grieve well. It even shows that people like to be frightened in the right dose. That is a finding about pleasure, and we should be careful not to read it as a finding about wisdom. I could also scrutinize the absent of lots of control variables in the experiment, but let’s not get there.
Woolley’s own work draws a line the decorations now cross. Her study asks whether a display depicts something that could really happen to a person and that would stir a negative emotion. If it does, she argues, children get the fear without the safety that makes fear useful. Glenn Sparks, a Purdue professor who studies frightening media, has warned that realistic Halloween imagery can terrify preschoolers, and that older children who seem to understand the fiction can still be shaken by it.
A warning from 1955
The question that most concerns me is why a society would want this at all. The most useful answer I know comes from an English anthropologist writing 71 years ago.
In 1955 Geoffrey Gorer published a short essay in the magazine Encounter titled “The Pornography of Death.” His claim startled readers then and still should. The Victorians, he argued, made sex unspeakable, and their prudery produced pornography, a private appetite for the very thing polite company refused to name. In the twentieth century, death took the place of sex. Ordinary dying, the slow decline of ordinary people in ordinary beds, became the new obscenity. As before, repression bred fantasy. Violent death filled horror comics, mass-market novels and Hollywood films, while real death vanished from conversation. If we keep death from the children, Gorer warned, we “almost ensure the continuation of the ‘horror comic.’”
Gorer had more than theory to prove his points. His brother died of cancer in 1961 after the family doctor advised that the diagnosis be kept from him. Gorer then surveyed 1,628 British adults about grief and mourning. In every case of terminal cancer the bereaved described to him, the dying person had been kept from knowing. Gorer believed the silence protected the living from the dying person’s fear as much as it protected the patient.
Psychology later supplied a mechanism that fits Gorer’s intuition. Terror management theory, developed by Jeff Greenberg, Tom Pyszczynski and Sheldon Solomon from the work of the anthropologist Ernest Becker. This theory posits that awareness of death produces an anxiety human beings manage through culture. Our customs and shared stories work as buffers, and experiments show that brief reminders of mortality change how people judge others and defend their beliefs.
When you read these two ideas together you see how they describe our Halloween quite uncomfortably well. A culture that will not speak of death plainly still needs to look at it. So it builds a stage where death can be viewed without being contemplated. The skeleton on your neighbor’s lawn lets us glance at mortality and laugh, and the laugh serves as a buffer of its own. The appeal of the glance at the death on the lawn is that it asks nothing of us.
The Gorer Gap
In a 2018 national survey by The Conversation Project, 92% of Americans said it was important to talk with loved ones about their wishes for end-of-life care. Only 32% had done it.
Set that beside the billions we spend each autumn on decorations, and you start to see an emerging pattern in view.
We will buy the image of death in bulk. We will not have the conversation.
I call this distance the Gorer Gap. This is the space between how freely a culture displays death and how rarely it speaks with the dying. A wide gap is a symptom. It tells you that a people has learned to handle death as decor. I make no claim that the decorations cause our silence. They thrive inside it, and every October they fill the space where grief and honest talk should be.
What the thrill does to us
A frightening image does something to us each time we see it. Fear is a signal as well as a feeling. And it alerts us to danger and moves us to protect someone. When the signal fades, we should ask what took its place.
In a 2007 experiment, Nicholas Carnagey, Craig Anderson and Brad Bushman had 257 college students play a violent or nonviolent video game for 20 minutes and then watch footage of real violence. Those who had played the violent game showed lower heart rates and weaker skin responses to the real footage. That study concerned video games, and a porch display is a far milder thing. It still illustrates a principle every psychologist knows as habituation. The body learns to stop reacting to what it sees often.
So the question for any household is what it wants its children to get used to. A child who sees a mutilated body on the neighbor’s lawn every October learns, at minimum, that such a sight belongs to celebration. I do not claim this child will grow cruel; at least for now, there is no longitudinal study showing evidence for this. A boy dressed as a ghost may become the kindest man on his street, and a woman who dislikes Halloween may treat people badly all year. The research does not support claims that Halloween makes anyone violent, and I will not make them. My claim is that every custom teaches something, and Halloween teaches that the ruin of a human body can serve as scenery.
A simulated corpse has no family waiting for news. Its wounds carry no history. We look, feel a jolt and walk on. Yet the image draws its power from things that are real: real victims, and in the case of hanging figures, the long history of wrongful hangings in this country that Woolley points to when she objects to them. The spectacle borrows the scene of agony and suffering and asks nothing of our care.
Halloween also teaches us what evil looks like. It hands us the grinning demon, the theatrical killer, the monster with exaggerated features. We laugh because we recognize the fiction.
Real evil is harder to spot because it enters a family through abuse. It settles into institutions where people learn to look past one another’s pain. A season spent making evil fun gives us little practice in naming it when it arrives without a mask.
What a body deserves
As a Christian, I feel this question with added weight. Human beings bear the image of God, and what happens to their bodies is quite significant for human dignity. Christian hope lets us face death without denying it and grieve without despair. That hope makes demands and asks us to stay with the dying, to bury the dead with honor and to keep company with those who mourn.
I struggle to reconcile that posture with mutilated bodies as festive scenery. The irony runs deep, I think. Because Halloween takes its name from All Hallows’ Eve, the night before the church remembers its saints. In the eighth century, Pope Gregory III set aside November 1 to honor them. Historians still argue over how much the holiday owes to the Gaelic festival of Samhain. The UCLA medievalist Henry Ansgar Kelly doubts the Samhain link and traces the holiday to the Christian calendar, while the Halloween historian Lisa Morton places it somewhere between the two. Either way, remembrance of the dead sat near its root. We kept the costume and lost the vigil.
Readers who do not share my faith can still ask the question at the heart of this essay. Does this celebration help us cherish human life? Flourishing includes how we live together and how we respond when someone becomes vulnerable. Our customs should give that concern room to grow.
Before you decorate your lawn this week
I am not asking anyone to bolt the door on Saturday night. You can if you want; at least that is exactly what my family will be doing. However, I am asking for caution, and I would begin with three tests.
The reality test
Ask whether the scene could actually happen to a person. If it shows real harm to a realistic human body, leave it in the box.
The child test
Picture the youngest child who will walk up your path and choose for the four-year-old. Older visitors can enjoy a pumpkin too.
The Gorer test
For every hour spent staging death, spend one with its reality. Call a grieving friend. Ask your parents what they want at the end.
The neighborly parts of Halloween are worth keeping. Open doors are important. So do shared meals and the delight a child takes in becoming a lion for one night. Hand out the candy. Learn the names of the families who come. Light a candle on November 1 for someone you have lost, and tell your children who that person was.
None of that requires turning a wound into an ornament.
We owe each other this tenderness
I would not describe every Halloween gathering as morally empty. People bring real goodness into customs whose imagery deserves criticism. But I cannot regard the yearly promotion of death and evil as entertainment as a worthy cause for a society that wants to flourish. Its pleasures give us too little reason to put simulated suffering at the center of a shared celebration.
I want children to grow less afraid as they come to understand the world. I also want them to keep the capacity to be troubled when a human being is harmed. Both can live in the same child, provided the adults around that child protect the second.
When death comes close to someone we love, we feel how much a single life weighs. Saturday will come either way. Before it does, walk to the end of your driveway and look back at your house the way a grieving neighbor would. Then decide what you want it to say, and what you want it to teach the children who climb your steps.
Sources
- National Retail Federation, “NRF Halloween Survey Shows Consumer Spending Expected to Reach $13.5 Billion,” Sept. 22, 2026. nrf.com
- Andersen, M. M., Schjoedt, U., Price, H., Rosas, F. E., Scrivner, C., & Clasen, M. (2020). Playing with fear: A field study in recreational horror. Psychological Science, 31(12), 1497–1510. PMC
- Scrivner, C., Johnson, J. A., Kjeldgaard-Christiansen, J., & Clasen, M. (2021). Pandemic practice: Horror fans and morbidly curious individuals are more psychologically resilient during the COVID-19 pandemic. Personality and Individual Differences. Author commentary: Nautilus
- Woolley, J. (2019, Oct. 30). Halloween is getting a little too scary. CNN, syndicated at KVIA
- Purdue University News (2014, Oct. 15). Halloween décor, fun and games not always kids’ stuff (Glenn Sparks). purdue.edu
- Gorer, G. (1955). The pornography of death. Encounter. Gorer, G. (1965). Death, Grief, and Mourning in Contemporary Britain. London: Cresset. Summary via Cambridge Core and IWM
- Greenberg, J., Pyszczynski, T., Solomon, S., et al. (1990). Evidence for terror management theory II. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 58(2), 308–318. Overview: University of Wyoming
- The Conversation Project National Survey (2018). theconversationproject.org
- Carnagey, N. L., Anderson, C. A., & Bushman, B. J. (2007). The effect of video game violence on physiological desensitization to real-life violence. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 43(3), 489–496.
- Library of Congress, Headlines & Heroes (2021). The origins of Halloween traditions. loc.gov; NBC/TODAY, What’s the real history of Halloween. nbcdfw.com
A LETTER FROM THE JOURNAL
Keep a little room
for a good idea.
Ideas for a flourishing life.
Receive the next essay.
Flourishing for the common good.
COUNTLIFE · NEWSLETTER
Ideas for a flourishing life.
Sign up to receive The Flourishing Journal by email.
Three Mental Health Crises in Our World Today
Identity, loneliness, and meaning look like three problems. I want to tell you why I think they are a problem of belonging.
Read the essay
Magnifica Humanitas and the Papal Letters That Built the Modern Idea of Human Dignity
Five popes. 135 years. One steadily widening answer to who counts as fully human. A short history of Catholic social teaching as it prepares to meet…
Read the essaySOMETHING ON YOUR MIND?Continue the conversation Speaking, research, media, or a personal note
How can we help?
Choose the form that fits your enquiry.
Contact Dr. Counted
COUNTLIFE · CONTACT
Let’s connect.
Send a question or a message to Dr. Victor Counted.
Speaking engagements
COUNTLIFE · SPEAKING
Invite Dr. Counted to speak.
Tell us about your event and the conversation you hope to begin.
Media and interviews
COUNTLIFE · MEDIA
Start a media conversation.
Enquire about interviews, commentary, or podcast appearances.
Research partnerships
COUNTLIFE · RESEARCH
Explore a research partnership.
Share your research question and the collaboration you have in mind.
Books and courses
COUNTLIFE · BOOKS
Ask about books or courses.
Get in touch about learning resources, group use, or an existing purchase.


THE CONVERSATION
What stayed with you?
Share a thought or question about this essay. Please keep comments relevant and respectful.
1 reader comment
This is a really good piece! Thanks Dr Counted