The Flourishing Journal

The Two Days After Halloween

  • Post published:
You are currently viewing The Two Days After Halloween
The Two Days After Halloween
Uncategorized

The Two Days After Halloween

Dr. Victor Counted  ·  November 2, 2026  ·  17 min read

Branded · Printable
The Two Days After Halloween | The Flourishing Journal
Essay Grief & Flourishing All Saints & All Souls

The Two Days After Halloween

Halloween ended on Saturday night. The two days that follow were built to do what a Halloween costume cannot. This week on closing the Gorer Gap.

On Sunday morning the skeletons will start coming down. By Monday the plastic bodies will be back in their bins in the garage, and the stores that sold them will be stocking tinsel. Actually, some of those stores will shut their doors and plan for another short lease for next October. Most of us will treat October 31 as the end of something. The church calendar treats it as a beginning to something much more significant.

In case you don’t know, halloween is the eve of a feast, and the feast runs for two more days.

Last week I wrote about “Revisiting the Pornography of Death” and an idea I called the Gorer Gap: the distance between how freely a culture displays death and how rarely it speaks with the dying. The essay struck a chord, with lots of comments on Facebook and other media platforms. The article also drew some new readers to The Flourishing Journal.

The three days we cut to one

Christians once called these days Hallowtide. October 31 is All Hallows’ Eve. November 1 is All Saints’ Day, which Pope Gregory III set aside in the eighth century to honor the saints. November 2 is All Souls’ Day. In the year 998, Abbot Odilo of Cluny made remembrance of the dead on that date obligatory in the monasteries under his care.

Look at the significance of those three days. A night when people faced the dark. A day to honor those who had lived faithfully and died. A day to pray for all the dead, the famous and the forgotten, by name. The sequence seems providential in that, when followed through, it can transform fear to memory to love. It takes a frightened people and walks them, step by step, toward the graves of their own families.

American culture kept the first night and threw away the other two. We kept the part that asks the least of us. This year All Saints’ Day falls on a Sunday, and All Souls’ Day on the Monday after. The calendar could hardly make the invitation plainer.

What grief science relearned

For much of the twentieth century, psychology told the bereaved to let go. The model descended from Freud’s idea of “grief work”. In it, the task of the mourner was to withdraw attachment from the dead and reinvest it in the living. A widow who still spoke to her husband’s photograph might be told, kindly, that she was stuck.

In 1996 three researchers challenged that view. Dennis Klass, Phyllis Silverman and Steven Nickman published Continuing Bonds: New Understandings of Grief, a collection of studies whose working title had been “Detachment Revisited.” They challenged the assumption that people must lose their ties to the dead to grieve well. Those ties could endure and help people live with loss.

That question runs through my own work on attachment disruption, where I look at what happens when a relationship can no longer continue in its familiar form. In my books The Roots of Radicalization, Place and Post-Pandemic Flourishing, and more recently, Caring With Despair, I have explored how people respond when their ties to people, places, and communities break or change. Much of this work concerns bonds with the living and with places that people can no longer inhabit as they once did. Several of my papers on these sorts of experiences have met with rejection from academic journals. Those experiences have made me attentive to how difficult it can be to question what a field assumes about attachment, loss, and recovery.

The continuing bonds literature speaks to this wider question. Because many mourners sustain a relationship with those who have died, and these bonds can support their well-being. They carry the relationship through memory or ritual, and the dead become part of who they are.

The research since then has been honest about limits. Recent reviews have not found that keeping bonds helps everyone, and outcomes vary across cultures and across kinds of loss. A bond can comfort, and in some cases it can keep a wound open. What the work did settle is that remembering the dead can sit alongside healing.

And did you know that a Benedictine abbot built a continuing-bonds practice into the calendar of the Church a thousand years before psychologists gave it a name? All Souls’ Day is a structure for staying connected to the dead: their names spoken aloud, their stories kept, their place in the community honored. It asks the living to remember together and on a fixed day, so that no one has to find the courage alone.

The Halloween’s skeleton invites us to glance at death and laugh. The All Souls’ Vigil invites us to sit with our dead and say their names.

What the conversation does

The second half of the Gorer Gap concerns the living who are dying. Recall the figures from last week. In a 2018 national survey, 92% of Americans said it was important to talk with loved ones about their wishes for end-of-life care, and only 32% had done it.

The silence has a price, and studies of dying patients show who pays it. In a 2008 study in JAMA, Alexi Wright, Holly Prigerson and colleagues followed 332 patients with advanced cancer. Only 37 percent had discussed end-of-life care with a doctor. Those who had were far less likely to die on machines: 1.6% received mechanical ventilation, against 11% of those who had not talked, and ICU admissions ran 4.1% against 12.4%. Aggressive care near death was linked to a worse final week for patients. Caregivers of patients who received it had more than three times the odds of major depression in bereavement.

That study observed patients and could not prove cause. A randomized trial helps. In 2010 Karen Detering and colleagues in Australia assigned 309 hospital patients aged 80 and over to receive help with advance care planning or usual care. Among those who died within six months, the wishes of patients who had planned were known and followed in 86% of cases, against 30% for the others. Their relatives reported less stress and less depression.

Geoffrey Gorer saw this in 1965, Death, Grief, and Mourning in Contemporary Britain. In every case of terminal cancer the bereaved described to him, the dying person had been kept from knowing. Silence left the dying alone, and it left their families with questions they could no longer ask.

The children at the door

Gorer’s most critical warning concerned children. If we make death unmentionable, “not before the children,” he wrote, we almost guarantee the horror comic. On Saturday night, thousands of children will walk past plastic corpses. Some of them already know what a real death feels like.

The 2026 Childhood Bereavement Estimation Model from Judi’s House projects that 1 in 11 children in the United States, more than 6.6 million, will experience the death of a parent or sibling by age 18. In an ordinary classroom of 22, that is two children. They are in our schools and youth groups. Many of them are learning, from the adults around them, that their grief is something to keep to themselves.

A culture that cannot talk about death leaves these children with costumes and no words. A household that can talk about it gives them something far better in return. One of those is the permission to say a name out loud and be met with tenderness instead of an awkward change of subject.

Mortal fluency

I confess that writing the essay from last week was easier than doing what it asks. Criticizing a neighbor’s lawn costs me nothing. Asking someone I love what they want at the end of their life costs a great deal, and knowing the research has not made that question easier to start.

That difficulty points to what we actually lack. Most of us already know we should have the conversation. But unfortunately, we lack practice. And by practice, I mean the shared habit of speaking about death plainly, grieving in company and staying connected to those we have lost. I call this capacity mortal fluency. Like any fluency, it grows through use and fades when a culture stops speaking the language.

There is evidence of hunger for it. In 2011 Jon Underwood invited a few people into his front room in Hackney, in east London, to talk about death over tea and cake. He called it a Death Cafe. By 2026 the project counted more than 20,000 of them in 93 countries. People are clearly willing to talk when someone opens the door.

Faith communities have had that door for centuries. Every congregation holds funerals, keeps prayer lists and knows who sat in the pew last year and is gone this year. Few communities are better placed to teach mortal fluency, and few are more tempted to leave it to the funeral home.

Practicing the vigil at scale

Mortal fluency should start small. And here are three places to begin this week or next year (since this article might come out on Monday).

SUNDAY

Say their names

Many faith communities read aloud the names of members who died this year. If yours does not, ask. At home, light a candle at dinner and let each person name someone they miss.

MONDAY

Tell one story

Pull out an old photograph and tell your children one true story about the person in it. Visit a grave if you can — you probably still have a tie to their tombstone. Let a child ask anything, and answer plainly.

THIS MONTH

Have the conversation

Ask a parent, spouse or friend what is most important to them at the end of life. Then tell them your own answer. Free guides from The Conversation Project can help you start.

For pastors or faith leaders, the opening is wider still. Preach or speak on death this month without hurrying to the resurrection. Host a conversation evening in the fellowship hall. Ask your elders to complete advance directives and to tell their families where the papers are. Make sure the grieving children in your congregation hear their parent’s or sibling’s name spoken by an adult who is not afraid of it.

A house of mourning

I have never seen a faith tradition that shy away from the theme of mourning. For example, the Christian faith asks believers to face death without despair. Biblical Paul expected the believers in Thessalonica to grieve, and he told them to “sorrow not, even as others which have no hope.” The communion of saints means the dead in Christ are not gone from the church. They are a great cloud of witnesses, and All Saints’ Day is the church’s annual act of remembering that.

“It is better to go to the house of mourning, than to go to the house of feasting: for that is the end of all men; and the living will lay it to his heart.”Ecclesiastes 7:2

Readers who do not share that hope can still take the author’s point in Ecclesiastes 7:2. People who make room for mourning live with more wisdom than people who only make room for feasting. Hallowtide offers both, in the right order.

Halloween asked us to glance at death and walk on. All Saints and All Souls ask us to stop, turn toward the people we have lost and the people we are losing, and say something meaningfully true. The first is easier, and it is the one our culture kept.

So the question I left you with last week has a second half. You have looked at your house the way a grieving neighbor would. Now look at your own table. Whose name has gone unspoken there this year? Monday is All Souls’ Day. Say it.

Sources
  1. Counted, V. (2026, Oct. 26). Revisiting the pornography of death. The Flourishing Journal.
  2. Library of Congress, Headlines & Heroes (2021). The origins of Halloween traditions. loc.gov
  3. Vatican News. Commemoration of all the faithful departed (All Souls’ Day). vaticannews.va
  4. Klass, D., Silverman, P. R., & Nickman, S. L. (Eds.). (1996). Continuing Bonds: New Understandings of Grief. Taylor & Francis. Overview: Continuing bonds
  5. The Conversation Project National Survey (2018). theconversationproject.org
  6. Wright, A. A., Zhang, B., et al. (2008). Associations between end-of-life discussions, patient mental health, medical care near death, and caregiver bereavement adjustment. JAMA, 300(14), 1665–1673. Summary: IAHPC
  7. Detering, K. M., et al. (2010). The impact of advance care planning on end of life care in elderly patients: Randomised controlled trial. BMJ, 340, c1345. Summary: HealthDay
  8. Gorer, G. (1955). The pornography of death. Encounter. Gorer, G. (1965). Death, Grief, and Mourning in Contemporary Britain.
  9. Judi’s House (2026). Childhood Bereavement Estimation Model: Key messages. judishouse.org
  10. Good Funeral Guide (2017). In memory of Jon Underwood. goodfuneralguide.co.uk; Newser (2026, May 4). Death cafés are bringing the taboo to light. newser.com
  11. Scripture quotations from the King James Version: 1 Thessalonians 4:13; Hebrews 12:1; Ecclesiastes 7:2.

Published in The Flourishing Journal
Flourishing for the common good.

THE CONVERSATION

What stayed with you?

Share a thought or question about this essay. Please keep comments relevant and respectful.

No approved comments yet. You are welcome to start the conversation.

Join the conversation

No account is needed. New comments appear after review. Your email address will not be displayed publicly.

A LETTER FROM THE JOURNAL

Keep a little room
for a good idea.

Ideas for a flourishing life.
Receive the next essay.

The Flourishing Journal
Flourishing for the common good.

COUNTLIFE · NEWSLETTER

Ideas for a flourishing life.

Sign up to receive The Flourishing Journal by email.

FOLLOW YOUR CURIOSITY

Read next

SOMETHING ON YOUR MIND?Continue the conversation Speaking, research, media, or a personal note

How can we help?

Choose the form that fits your enquiry.

Contact Dr. Counted

COUNTLIFE · CONTACT

Let’s connect.

Send a question or a message to Dr. Victor Counted.

Speaking engagements

COUNTLIFE · SPEAKING

Invite Dr. Counted to speak.

Tell us about your event and the conversation you hope to begin.

Media and interviews

COUNTLIFE · MEDIA

Start a media conversation.

Enquire about interviews, commentary, or podcast appearances.

Research partnerships

COUNTLIFE · RESEARCH

Explore a research partnership.

Share your research question and the collaboration you have in mind.

Books and courses

COUNTLIFE · BOOKS

Ask about books or courses.

Get in touch about learning resources, group use, or an existing purchase.